Photo: steelers.com

Steelers Surprises: An Unthinkable Collapse Against the Bengals

The Pittsburgh Steelers entered Sunday night’s matchup with the Cincinnati Bengals having won four consecutive games, fresh off a bye week, and with an opportunity to put some distance between themselves and a division rival. There was every reason to expect a competitive game, especially after Pittsburgh won the first meeting between these teams earlier this season.

Instead, the Steelers were embarrassed in a 38-18 loss that exposed problems on both sides of the football. Cincinnati dominated the first three quarters, and Pittsburgh’s late touchdowns did little to disguise just how badly things went.

Usually, this weekly surprises column includes a few unexpected bright spots mixed in with the disappointments. Not this time. There were plenty of surprises in Cincinnati, but almost none were the kind Steelers fans wanted to see.

Embed from Getty Images

The Steelers Barely Touched the Football in the First Quarter

One of the most astonishing statistics from Sunday night’s game came before the Steelers even had a chance to settle in. Cincinnati controlled the football for 14 minutes of the opening quarter, leaving Pittsburgh’s offense with just 60 seconds of possession.

The Bengals opened with a lengthy field goal drive, then followed Pittsburgh’s first three-and-out with another possession that carried into the second quarter and ended in a touchdown. By the time the Steelers had another opportunity, they were already trailing 10-0.

It’s difficult to establish any offensive rhythm when the other team refuses to give you the football. However, Pittsburgh didn’t help itself by gaining only three yards on its opening possession. The defense couldn’t get off the field, and the offense couldn’t stay on it. That combination set the tone for everything that followed.

Joe Burrow Didn’t Even Need Third Downs

Here’s a statistic that might surprise anyone who didn’t watch the game: Cincinnati converted only two of its seven third-down opportunities. Ordinarily, holding an opponent to a 28.6% conversion rate would be considered a successful defensive performance.

Unfortunately, those numbers are meaningless when the opposing offense is picking up first downs before reaching third down in the first place.

The Bengals finished with 30 first downs, including 23 through the air, while averaging 7.4 yards per offensive play.

Joe Burrow completed 35 of 44 passes for 409 yards and four touchdowns. The Steelers rarely disrupted his timing, and Cincinnati repeatedly found ways to move the chains without encountering much resistance. Pittsburgh’s inability to force difficult situations was just as concerning as its inability to stop the big plays.

Embed from Getty Images

Ja’Marr Chase Was Practically the Entire Steelers Passing Offense by Himself

We knew Ja’Marr Chase would be a problem. He’s one of the NFL’s most dangerous receivers, and the Steelers certainly weren’t going to shut him down completely. But allowing one player to accumulate more receiving yards than Pittsburgh’s entire offense managed through the air is something else entirely.

Chase caught 11 passes for 231 yards, including gains of 53, 43, and 35 yards. Meanwhile, the Steelers finished with just 120 net passing yards as a team. Chase nearly doubled that total on his own.

What’s particularly disturbing is that Cincinnati didn’t need Chase to score a touchdown. Burrow distributed his four scoring passes to other targets while Chase repeatedly shredded Pittsburgh’s coverage between the end zones. The Steelers couldn’t contain him, and there never appeared to be a convincing adjustment to change that.

Payton Wilson‘s 18 Tackles Were a Bad Sign

Payton Wilson finished with 18 combined tackles, an eye-popping number that might look impressive without any additional context. Patrick Queen added 14 tackles and Pittsburgh’s only sack, while Jaquan Brisker recorded 10 tackles of his own.

Those totals weren’t evidence of a dominant defensive effort. They were a reflection of how frequently Cincinnati possessed the football and how often Pittsburgh defenders were forced to make tackles after the Bengals had already gained significant yardage.

Perhaps the most alarming statistic from Sunday night’s loss was the lack of production from Pittsburgh’s defensive front. T.J. Watt recorded just one tackle, while Cam Heyward, Nick Herbig, Derrick Harmon, Alex Highsmith, and Keeanu Benton each managed only one assisted tackle.

That’s six combined tackles from those six players, compared to a staggering 42 combined tackles from Brisker, Wilson, and Queen. Those numbers tell you just how badly the Steelers were getting beaten up front and how frequently Cincinnati was reaching the second and third levels of Pittsburgh’s defense.

The Steelers spent more than 35 minutes on defense, surrendering 484 yards and five touchdowns. Wilson’s activity was impossible to ignore, but having your defenders pile up tackles while the opposing offense marches up and down the field isn’t a recipe for winning football.

Embed from Getty Images

Three Steelers Fumbles Somehow Didn’t Become Turnovers

For all the problems Pittsburgh experienced offensively, the Steelers somehow managed to finish the game without officially turning the football over. That’s surprising considering the gamebook credited Pittsburgh with three fumbles involving Aaron Rodgers, Zach Frazier, and Jaylen Warren.

That may have flown under the radar, especially since Rodgers recovered from the bad snaps and Warren’s fumble was recovered. However, imagine the additional damage in a game that was already getting out of hand!

On the other hand, Cincinnati also finished without a turnover, despite Jalen Ramsey forcing a Ja’Marr Chase fumble that the Bengals recovered.

Ordinarily, winning the turnover battle or simply protecting the football gives a team a reasonable opportunity to compete. Pittsburgh didn’t even need turnovers to lose by 20 points. The Steelers were so thoroughly outplayed that Cincinnati had no need for extra possessions or short fields to build its commanding lead.

Two Touchdowns, Yet Nothing to Show for the Red Zone

Another unusual statistic from Sunday night was Pittsburgh finishing with two passing touchdowns while going 0-for-2 in red-zone opportunities. Both scores came from outside the 20-yard line, with Aaron Rodgers connecting with DK Metcalf for 22 yards and Pat Freiermuth for 27 yards for fourth quarter “garbage time” scores.

Those plays might have been encouraging under different circumstances, but Pittsburgh was already trailing 31-3 when the first touchdown was scored.

The Steelers couldn’t finish either of their actual red-zone trips with a touchdown, including their final possession that ended with the clock running out.

Meanwhile, Cincinnati scored touchdowns on five of its six red-zone possessions. The difference in execution was staggering, particularly considering the Steelers had an additional week to prepare for this matchup.

Embed from Getty Images

The Biggest Surprise Was How Unprepared Pittsburgh Looked

Of everything that happened Sunday night, this might be the most difficult part to explain. The Steelers weren’t coming off a short week or traveling into unfamiliar territory against an opponent they hadn’t studied. They had already beaten Cincinnati once, had two weeks between games, and knew exactly what was at stake.

Yet the Bengals looked sharper, faster, and better prepared in virtually every phase. Pittsburgh had just 40 total yards at halftime, trailed by 21 points, and never seriously threatened to make a game of it.

Mike McCarthy and his coaching staff have plenty to answer for after this performance. Losing to a talented division opponent is one thing. Looking completely overwhelmed after a bye week is another.

The Steelers are still 6-3, and there’s plenty of football remaining. But Sunday’s loss wasn’t merely disappointing because of the final score. It was surprising because a team that appeared to be finding its identity suddenly looked like it had no answers whatsoever.

More Steelers News and Analysis

Pittsburgh Steelers DE Cameron Heyward

Steelers Surprises: An Unthinkable Collapse Against the Bengals

  • Postgame
  • by Joe Kuzma
Read More
Pittsburgh Steelers WR DK Metcalf

Watch: DK Metcalf Scores Steelers’ First Touchdown Against Bengals

  • Highlights
  • by Joe Kuzma
Read More
Steelers Look Completely Lost in Embarrassing Loss to Bengals

Steelers Look Completely Lost in Embarrassing Loss to Bengals

  • Postgame Podcast
  • by Joe Kuzma and Brian E. Roach
Watch/Listen Now

Steelers Takeaways: Nothing Goes Right in Blowout Loss to Bengals

  • Postgame
  • by Joe Kuzma
Read More
Pittsburgh Steelers TE Pat Freiermuth

Watch: Pat Freiermuth Plows Through Bengals on 27-Yard TD

  • Highlights
  • by Joe Kuzma
Read More
Pittsburgh Steelers QB Aaron Rodgers

SCU Week in Review – November 15th

  • Week in Review
  • by Joe Kuzma
Read More

Suggestions From Our Sponsors